Top 10 Print-on-Demand Puzzles Suppliers for Creators

Personalized puzzles are rapidly gaining popularity in the print-on-demand (POD) market, appealing to customers seeking unique, meaningful gifts and activities. For artists, designers, and small companies wishing to increase the variety of products they offer, this growing demand creates new creative and business opportunities.

Selecting the best print-on-demand puzzle suppliers for Creators is crucial if you want to succeed in this market.  A reliable supplier ensures quality, customization options, and smooth fulfillment elements that directly impact your brand's reputation and customer satisfaction.

Print On Demand Puzzle Suppliers Comparison Table

Important Things to Look for in a Puzzle Supplier

1. Product Quality

The feel and finish of your puzzle speak volumes about your brand. Customers notice the difference.

• Material matters: Look for suppliers offering sturdy cardboard or premium wood with proper thickness to avoid bending.
• Finish options: Choose between matte and glossy finishes depending on the aesthetic you want to deliver.
• Print clarity: Ensure high-resolution, edge-to-edge printing. Blurry images are a dealbreaker.

📌 Example: A 1000-piece art puzzle with vivid colors and sharp lines can turn into a frame-worthy display.

2. Customization Options

The more customizable your product, the more it reflects your unique brand identity.

• Provide a range of puzzle sizes and piece counts, such as 120, 500, or 1000.
• Tailor the puzzle box's packaging to highlight your branding.
• For a personal touch, include extras like inserts or message cards

💡 Offering the same design in various sizes can draw in puzzle fans as well as casual purchasers.

3. Shipping & Fulfillment

Building client loyalty and trust requires prompt and dependable shipping.

• Choose suppliers with quick production times and dependable shipping services.
• Make sure they deliver to your target regions, such as the US, the EU, or Australia.
• Tracking options are essential so customers can follow their orders.

📦 Suppliers with production centers in multiple regions can reduce delivery times and customs issues.

4. Platform Integrations

Automation is your friend when running an online store.

• Look for suppliers that integrate with Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, or similar platforms.
• Advanced users may benefit from API access for custom-built solutions.

⚙️ Seamless integration means orders sync automatically, reducing manual work and errors.

5. Branding Features

Your packaging is part of the customer experience. Make it count.

• To draw attention to your logo and design aesthetic, use custom box printing.
• To avoid mentioning the supplier, go with white-label options.
• Add little extras like care instructions or thank-you notes. 🎁 When your puzzle is packaged with a brand, opening it becomes an unforgettable experience.

6. Pricing & Profit Margins

• Knowing your cost structure enables you to set wise prices and maintain profitability.
• Examine unit prices, shipping costs, and any other expenses.
• Find out if the supplier provides reduced prices or bulk discounts for regular orders.
• Determine your profit margins by using your retail pricing strateg

📊 Ideally, aim for a 30–50% profit margin to cover marketing, fees, and unexpected expenses.

7. Support & Reliability

Your POD business may succeed or fail based on your customer service.

• Test their support response time before committing.
• Ask about their policy on damaged, late, or lost orders.
• Look for reviews or testimonials from other sellers for real-world insights.

🤝 A responsive, dependable supplier is worth more than a cheap one that disappears when issues arise.

Top 10 Print-on-Demand Puzzle Suppliers for Creators

#1. Printify

One of the best options for artists venturing into the print-on-demand space is Printify. It makes it simple to transform your designs into customized puzzles by connecting you with a large global network of print providers. Printify provides the resources to launch puzzle products without having to worry about inventory or shipping, regardless of your background as an artist, photographer, or small business owner.

Puzzle Quality

Printify puzzles are known for their customizability and vibrant finish. Here's a closer look at the quality you can expect:

• Material: Made from 2.4mm high-density chipboard, puzzles are sturdy and inflexible, reducing warping and bending when in use or transit.
• Finish: A satin or semi-gloss coating that makes artwork stand out by lowering glare and enhancing the vibrancy of printed colors.
• Printing: Full-bleed digital printing with high DPI resolution captures intricate details and smooth gradients, perfect for both photos and graphic designs.
• Durability: The quality may differ based on the print partner used, but puzzle pieces fit tightly with tight interlocking edges to avoid gaps or looseness over time.
• Packaging: Depending on the supplier, it offers customizable packaging options with branding opportunities; however, sample ordering is strongly advised to ensure consistency.
• Pricing: Depending on size and provider, base prices typically range from $10 to $25. Profit margins are increased by offering up to 20% discounts to Printify Premium members.

Pros

• Durable materials with sharp, vivid printing
• Multiple puzzle sizes and customizable packaging
• Professional branded boxes to boost brand identity
• Easy integrations with Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, and more
• Automated order handling and access to global fulfillment partners

Cons

• Product quality can vary between print providers
• Packaging styles and finishes differ by supplier
• Some international providers may have longer fulfillment times

Printify is best suited for creators who want full design control, professional-quality puzzles, and a hands-off, automated fulfillment process.

Read our detailed POD provider Printify review here!

#2. PrintKK

PrintKK is an emerging player in the print-on-demand puzzle market, providing creators with an easy-to-use platform to produce custom puzzles featuring vibrant designs. It's a great option for artists and small businesses seeking quality products with straightforward ordering and reliable production.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: Thick, industrial-grade cardboard known for its sturdiness and resilience, able to withstand repeated assembly without damage.
• Finish: Smooth semi-gloss coating protects the surface from fingerprints and scuffs while enhancing the color richness of prints.
• Printing: Utilizes HD digital printing technology producing vibrant colors and sharp, crisp details, which hold well even on complex artwork.
• Durability: Laser-cut puzzle pieces are precisely made to ensure a tight, seamless fit that resists warping and bending, offering a satisfying puzzling experience.
• Packaging: Comes in solid cardboard boxes designed to protect the puzzle during transit; customization options are limited but packaging remains retail-ready.
• Sizes: Primarily focuses on 500-piece puzzles, providing an ideal balance between challenge and approachability.
• Price: Price-wise, they are competitive, often falling into mid-range for custom puzzles; so, they are an affordable option for a creator trying to make in road into the print-on-demand puzzle market.

Pros

• High-quality materials with sturdy, tight-fitting pieces
• Bright, vivid printing with clear details
• Semi-gloss finish that reduces glare and enhances visuals
• Simple ordering process
• Competitive pricing that fits many budgets

Cons

• Limited puzzle size options, mainly 500 pieces
• Fewer branding and packaging customization choices
• Shipping times and coverage may vary depending on location

PrintKK is ideal for creators who want high-quality, visually appealing puzzles with a focus on ease of use and mid-sized products without needing extensive customization features.

#3. InkedJoy

InkedJoy stands out as a creative print-on-demand platform catering to artists and creators who want to bring their designs to life on puzzles. Known for its focus on quality and customization, InkedJoy offers a straightforward way to produce personalized puzzles that appeal to puzzle lovers and gift shoppers alike.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: Premium 2.5mm thick chipboard provides a sturdy, durable base that resists wear and tear during extended puzzle use.
• Finish: Matte finish reduces glare, offering a refined and sophisticated look, which allows fine details and subtle colors to stand out.
• Printing: Uses UV-curable inks that are vibrant, fade-resistant, and environmentally friendly, preserving design integrity for long-term enjoyment.
• Durability: Pieces are cut to fit snugly, preventing unnecessary friction or damage during repeated assembly contributing to high customer satisfaction.
• Packaging: Delivered in robust, minimalist packaging that protects the puzzle while maintaining a clean, professional presentation.
• Sizes: Focused mainly on 500-piece puzzles, catering to a broad range of puzzle enthusiasts.
• Pricing: Their pricing is reasonable, making InkedJoy a cost-effective option for creators who want to offer high-quality puzzles without a significant upfront investment.

Pros

• Durable materials with tightly fitting pieces
• Matte finish that reduces glare and highlights artwork
• Crisp, vibrant printing quality
• Easy-to-use platform for quick order processing
• Competitive pricing for quality puzzles

Cons

• Limited puzzle size variety, mainly focused on 500 pieces
• Fewer packaging customization options
• Shipping speed and coverage can vary depending on location

InkedJoy is a great fit for creators who want high-quality, visually appealing puzzles with a simple ordering system, especially when focusing on puzzles that are medium in size and appeal to a wide range of customers.

#4. Zazzle

Zazzle is a well-established print-on-demand marketplace that allows creators to design and sell custom puzzles with ease. Known for its wide product range and user-friendly platform, Zazzle appeals to artists, photographers, and small businesses aiming to add personalized puzzles to their product lineup.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: Utilizes eco-friendly, 2.4mm thick cardboard, offering both durability and an environmentally conscious option.
• Finish: Semi-gloss coating enhances colors with a gentle shine, balancing vibrancy without overwhelming glare.
• Printing: Advanced UV digital printing technology ensures precise reproduction of fine textures and gradients, ideal for detailed artwork.
• Durability: Puzzle pieces fit tightly and maintain shape after multiple uses, ensuring a quality puzzling experience.
• Packaging: Comes in strong, protective boxes suitable for gifting, although packaging customization is minimal.
• Sizes: Offers a range from 252 to 1000 pieces, appealing to all skill levels.
• Pricing: Pricing varies depending on puzzle size and customization, with competitive rates that make Zazzle a viable option for creators seeking quality puzzles without high upfront costs.

Pros

• Reliable materials with tight-fitting pieces
• Semi-gloss finish that boosts color brightness and detail
• Multiple puzzle sizes to suit different audiences
• User-friendly platform with easy design upload
• Strong brand presence and marketplace exposure

Cons

• Limited packaging customization
• During busy seasons, some customers complain about lengthier shipment delays.
• Quality can vary slightly depending on design and size.

Zazzle is a strong choice for creators who want a trusted platform with multiple puzzle sizes, vibrant prints, and an established marketplace that can help boost visibility and sales.

#5. Contrado

Contrado is a premium print-on-demand supplier known for its exceptional quality and attention to detail. It is a popular choice for creators looking to offer high-end custom puzzles. With a focus on craftsmanship and vibrant printing, Contrado appeals to artists and small businesses aiming to provide a standout product that impresses customers.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: Uses thick, 3mm premium-grade cardboard, providing a luxurious feel and exceptional sturdiness.
• Finish: Smooth satin finish with UV protection prevents fading and surface scratches, keeping colors bright over time.
• Printing: Dye-sublimation printing deeply embeds colors, resulting in vibrant, sharp images that maintain clarity even after prolonged use.
• Durability: Precision die-cut pieces fit perfectly, enhancing puzzle stability and durability during repeated assemblies.
• Packaging: Premium, fully customizable boxes with options like magnetic closures add to the unboxing experience.
• Sizes: Mainly offers 500 and 1000-piece puzzles, catering to beginners and advanced puzzlers alike.
• Pricing: Contrado's pricing is positioned at the higher end of the market, reflecting the premium materials and print quality. This makes it ideal for creators who want to prioritize quality and branding over low cost.

Pros

• High-quality, durable materials with precise piece fitting
• The satin finish that beautifully showcases colors and details
• Customizable packaging to enhance brand identity
• Excellent print clarity suitable for detailed artwork
• High priority for customer satisfaction and product quality

Cons

• Higher pricing compared to many other POD suppliers
• A smaller range of puzzle sizes
• Shipping costs can be higher due to premium production standards

Contrado is perfect for creators who want to offer luxurious, high-quality puzzles with strong branding opportunities and who are willing to invest a bit more for a standout product.

#6. Threadless

Threadless is a creative marketplace and print-on-demand platform known for showcasing unique artwork from independent artists. It offers custom puzzles as part of its diverse product lineup, making it an attractive option for creators who want to reach a community that appreciates original, artistic designs.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: High-quality 2.5mm chipboard offers solid structure, although slightly less rigid than some competitors.
• Finish: Semi-gloss coating provides vibrant color reproduction while managing glare effectively.
• Printing: Uses digital pigment printing, delivering consistent color fidelity and sharp details across the entire puzzle.
• Durability: Puzzle pieces fit snugly but cater more to casual users than serious puzzlers.
• Packaging: Basic but sturdy boxes protect puzzles well, with limited branding opportunities.
• Sizes: Focused on 252-piece puzzles, ideal for moderate difficulty levels.
• Pricing: The cost is reasonable and commensurate with the caliber of the printing and materials. This makes Threadless a good option for creators who want to offer attractive puzzles without a high upfront cost.

Pros

• Strong focus on artist-driven designs and creative community
• Durable materials with precise piece fitting
• Vibrant printing with semi-gloss finish
• User-friendly platform with an existing customer base
• Affordable pricing for quality puzzles

Cons

• Limited puzzle size options
• Packaging customization is minimal
• Less suitable for creators seeking bulk or large-scale orders

Threadless is ideal for artists and small businesses wanting to tap into a creative marketplace with quality puzzles that highlight original designs in an accessible size.

#7. Prodigi

Prodigi is a global print-on-demand supplier known for its extensive product range and strong commitment to quality. It offers custom puzzles designed for creators who want a balance of professional-grade materials and reliable fulfillment services, making it ideal for artists and small businesses targeting puzzle lovers.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: Made from 2.7mm recycled chipboard, combining durability with eco-friendliness.
• Finish: A smooth satin finish enhances color saturation and reduces glare for an enjoyable viewing experience.
• Printing: Pigment-based inks offer excellent fade resistance and capture fine image details perfectly.
• Durability: Laser-cut pieces fit tightly for seamless assembly and minimal wear.
• Packaging: Simple, sturdy boxes designed for protection; limited branding options.
• Sizes: Typically available in 252 and 500-piece puzzles.
• Pricing: The pricing is competitive, offering good value for quality materials and print standards. This allows creators to maintain healthy profit margins without compromising the product.

Pros

• Durable materials with tight-fitting puzzle pieces
• The satin finish that enhances color vibrancy and detail
• Multiple size options for a broad audience
• Reliable global fulfillment network with fast shipping
• Easy-to-use platform with seamless integration options

Cons

• Limited packaging customization
• A smaller variety of puzzle sizes compared to some competitors
• May have longer fulfillment times in some regions

Prodigi is a solid choice for creators who prioritize quality and dependable service, offering puzzles that impress customers while streamlining order management.

#8. Gooten

Gooten is a versatile print-on-demand platform that caters to creators looking to add custom puzzles to their product line. Known for its wide range of print products and seamless integration with popular e-commerce platforms, Gooten offers a flexible solution for artists and small businesses wanting to expand into puzzles without the hassle of inventory management.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: 2.3mm chipboard, balancing cost-effectiveness with reasonable durability.
• Finish: Semi-gloss coating brightens colors and offers scratch resistance.
• Printing: Employs dye-sub or UV printing methods for sharp, vibrant designs.
• Durability: Pieces fit snugly, but print quality can sometimes vary between batches.
• Packaging: Standard protective packaging ensures safe delivery but with few customization options.
• Sizes: Primarily offers 252-piece puzzles.
• Pricing: Pricing is competitive and affordable, making Gooten a good choice for creators who want quality puzzles without a high upfront cost, helping to maintain reasonable profit margins.

Pros

• Durable materials with well-fitting pieces
• Vibrant, high-quality prints with a semi-gloss finish
• Easy integration with platforms like Shopify and Etsy
• Competitive pricing suitable for small businesses
• Reliable order fulfillment and shipping

Cons

• Limited puzzle size options
• Packaging customization is minimal
• Some variability in print quality depending on fulfillment location

Gooten is a practical choice for creators seeking dependable quality and cost-effective puzzles, especially those new to the print-on-demand puzzle niche and looking for simple, scalable options.

Read our detailed Gooten POD provider review here!

#9. Merchize

Merchize is a fast-growing print-on-demand platform that offers a wide variety of customizable products, including puzzles. It's popular among creators and small businesses because of its user-friendly interface and efficient order fulfillment, allowing you to focus on your designs while merchandise handles production and shipping.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: Uses 2.5mm thick premium cardboard with glossy surface treatment.
• Finish: Glossy coating intensifies color depth and protects against scratches.
• Printing: High-resolution digital printing produces bright, vivid images with excellent detail.
• Durability: Well-cut pieces fit precisely, designed for multiple uses without damage.
• Packaging: Allows some customization of packaging, helping brands stand out.
• Sizes: Offers puzzles mainly in 252 and 500 pieces.
• Pricing: The pricing is competitive, with reasonable base costs that allow creators to maintain good profit margins. Bulk order discounts and membership plans offer additional savings.

Pros

• Strong, durable puzzle pieces with precise fit
• Vibrant prints with detailed image clarity
• Packaging customization to strengthen brand identity
• Competitive pricing with discounts for bulk orders
• Smooth integration with popular e-commerce platforms

Cons

• Limited puzzle size variety compared to some competitors
• Packaging options could be expanded for more personalization
• Slight variations in print quality depending on the fulfillment location

Merchize is an excellent option for creators seeking a balance of quality, affordability, and branding opportunities, especially those who want to offer puzzles as part of a diverse product lineup.

#10. 99DIY

99DIY is a specialized print-on-demand service focused on personalized puzzles, making it a great choice for creators who want detailed customization options. It appeals to artists, photographers, and small business owners looking for high-quality puzzles with unique designs.

Puzzle Quality

• Material: 2.6mm thick, heavy-duty chipboard offering robust strength and long-lasting use.
• Finish: Smooth semi-gloss finish that reduces glare and makes colors pop.
• Printing: Dye-sublimation printing yields crisp, vibrant images with excellent detail retention.
• Durability: Tight-fitting pieces reduce wear and improve puzzle longevity.
• Packaging: Fully customizable branded boxes, enhancing gift appeal and retail presentation.
• Sizes: Popular sizes include 252 and 500 pieces, suitable for a wide range of customers.
• Pricing: Pricing is competitive and transparent, allowing creators to price their products effectively. Bulk order discounts and flexible pricing models help improve profit margins for small businesses.

Pros

• Durable chipboard with tightly fitting pieces
• Crisp, vivid printing with a smooth finish
• Customizable branded packaging for enhanced customer experience
• A variety of puzzle sizes suited for all skill levels
• Transparent pricing and bulk discounts for better margins

Cons

• Limited international shipping options may affect global sellers
• Some customization options may have longer production times
• A smaller company size means fewer integrations with major e-commerce platforms

99DIY stands out for creators who want quality, customization, and an attractive packaging solution, making it ideal for those focused on unique, personalized puzzles with a professional finish.

Useful Tips for Selling Print-on-Demand Puzzles

1. Target a Niche Audience

Going niche helps you build a loyal audience and makes your products easier to market.

• Examples of high-converting niches are pet lovers (custom dog puzzles), travel enthusiasts (city map puzzles), mental wellness (affirmation puzzles), or romantic gifts (anniversary photo puzzles).
• Why it works: Niche audiences are more emotionally connected, more likely to share, and easier to target with ads.

Instead of "custom puzzles for everyone," try "Vintage Japanese Travel Puzzle Series" or "Mindfulness Quote Puzzles for Anxiety Relief."

2. Use High-Quality Visuals

Good visuals build trust. Great visuals sell the product.

• Use lifestyle mockups: show puzzles on coffee tables, in cozy living rooms, or as part of family game night.
• Include close-up shots: highlight the piece cut, color clarity, and print texture.
• Try before-and-after visuals: original photo → finished puzzle.

Tip: If you can't afford a photographer, use smart mockup tools like Placeit or PSD templates to simulate real settings.

3. Offer Personalization

Personalized puzzles are highly giftable, and gifts sell year-round.

• Allow customers to upload photos, add names, or include a message on the box.
• Promote ideas like "Valentine's Day Couple Puzzle" or "Birthday Photo Puzzle Keepsake."
• Charge more: Personalized puzzles typically support 30% higher pricing than generic ones.

Example: A simple $18 puzzle becomes a $29 "Custom Wedding Keepsake Puzzle with Gift Box."

4. Optimize Listings for SEO

Being on Etsy or Shopify isn't enough; your product needs to be found.

• Use keywords like "custom photo puzzle," "1000-piece puzzle for adults," or "personalized family puzzle."
• Place top keywords in the title, bullet points, description, and tags.
• Each listing should have a unique copy — avoid copy-pasting manufacturer blurbs.

Pro tip: Use tools like EtsyHunt, KeywordTool.io, or Google Trends to refine your SEO.

5. Launch Seasonal Campaigns

Seasonal designs help you stay relevant and create urgency.

• Create holiday-themed puzzles: Christmas, Halloween, Valentine's Day, etc.
• Use countdowns: "Order by Dec 15 for Christmas Delivery."
• Run promos like "Buy 1 Get 1 30% Off" for seasonal bundles.

Example: Launch a "12 Days of Puzzle-mas" collection during December.

6. Bundle and Upsell

Smart product pairings make every sale more profitable.

• Offer add-ons: a second copy of the puzzle at a discount, a framed version, or a matching tote bag.
• Create bundles: "Puzzle + Poster," "2 Custom Puzzles = Free Gift Box Upgrade."

Use cart upsell apps (like ReConvert or Bold Upsell) to automate this strategy.

7. Gather Reviews & UGC

User-generated content (UGC) builds trust and drives social proof.

• Encourage customers to post their completed puzzles and tag you for a discount.
• Feature top photos in your product gallery and ads.
• Ask for video reviews; these work great on TikTok and Instagram Reels.

Bonus: Run a monthly "Puzzle of the Month" giveaway to encourage participation.

8. Test Before Scaling

Not all print providers deliver an equal quality. Verify before you commit.

• Order a sample puzzle from each supplier you plan to use.
• Check the packaging, print resolution, puzzle cut precision, and shipping time.
• Use your sample photos in your listings for transparency.

Think long-term: one negative review due to poor print quality can hurt more than 10 good ones.

Avoid These Costly Mistakes When Selling POD Puzzles

Even the best design can fail if you fall into these avoidable traps. Here's what to watch out for:

1. Choosing Suppliers Based Solely on Price

Although they might be alluring, low prices frequently include unstated costs.

• Cheaper suppliers may cut corners on print resolution, material quality, or packaging.
• Prioritize value over cost: compare pricing alongside customer reviews, sample quality, and fulfillment reliability.

Remember: a few extra dollars for higher quality can prevent bad reviews and refunds later.

2. Ignoring Shipping Time or International Fees

Slow or expensive shipping can kill customer satisfaction quickly.

• Double-check estimated delivery times, especially for the holiday season.
• Watch out for hidden international surcharges, customs delays, or lack of tracking info.
• If your main audience is in the US or Europe, try to work with fulfillment centers near those regions.

Solution: Clearly communicate shipping timelines on your product page to manage expectations.

3. Overlooking Packaging & Branding Quality

Packaging isn't just protection; it's part of the customer experience.

• Some suppliers use generic or bland boxes that don't reflect your brand.
• Customers are more likely to give and recommend a product that comes in branded, well-designed packaging.

Always ask if you can add a logo, insert, or custom box when evaluating POD suppliers.

4. Skipping Sample Testing Before Launch

Launching unquestioningly is one of the fastest ways to hurt your store.

• Without a sample, you won't know how the final product feels, looks, or holds up over time.
• Common issues include blurry images, puzzle pieces that don't fit well, or weak packaging.

Order and test every variant (size, finish, provider) before listing it for sale; treat your samples like an audit.

5. Poor SEO = Low Visibility, No Sales

Your product can be amazing, but if nobody finds it, it won't sell.

• Many sellers forget to optimize titles, tags, and descriptions or use overly vague terms like "cool puzzle."
• Without proper SEO, your puzzle won't appear in Etsy, Google, or marketplace searches.

Use specific keywords like "1000-piece custom travel puzzle" or "personalized dog photo jigsaw" to improve discovery.

Read more: 

• How To Start a Print-On-Demand Business
• 21 Best Successful Print On Demand Websites To Learn From
• 15 Best Shopify POD Apps FREE 
• 12 Best Shopify Themes for Print on Demand Stores

Conclusion

Print-on-demand puzzles are gaining serious traction in the creative eCommerce world. They combine personalization, entertainment, and emotional value, making them a unique product that stands out in a crowded market. Whether you're an artist, designer, or entrepreneur, puzzles offer a great way to showcase your creativity and connect with customers on a deeper level.

But to succeed, choosing the right supplier is crucial. Don't just focus on low prices—look for quality materials, reliable shipping, and strong branding options. Start small, test a few suppliers, and only scale once you're confident in the results. With the right approach, POD puzzles can become a standout product in your store.